Shelby
County History

| 1831/1832 | It is claimed that George Turner was the first actual settler in Dinsmore twp. It is also claimed that later in the same year, Joseph green and John Munch settled. Other sources say tha William Blakeley came here from Franklin county in 1831 and during the same year, Silas D. Allen came from Pickaway county. |
| 1832 | *John Munch
came from
Greene county with his wife and eight children.
*George Turner also came from Greene County, but left ten months later on account of the prevelance of milk sickness. George returned in 1837. *Richard Dill came from Hamilton county with his wife and eleven kids. *Joseph Green came from Warren county with his wife and five kids. * Samuel Blakeley came from Franklin county to Franklin twp in 1830, but moved here two years later. *Richard Botkin came from Hamilton county. |
| 1833 | *Alfred Staley
came from
Montgomery county *Erasmus B. Toland with his wife and two children came from Miami county *Philip Good came from Greene county (originally from PA) *Hector Lemon came from Chester County, PA *Jospeh Park came from NJ *Philip Hagelberger of France |
| 1834 | *David Taylor
came from
Greene county with wife and eight children *Peter Boling came from Montgomery county *Philip Brideweiser came from Franklin county *William Ellis came from VA *Joseph Bruner came from Clark county *Jacob Wiford with wife and five children came from VA *Frederick Oxburger of Germany *Samuel & William Elliott |
| 1835 | *Thomas Iiams
came from
Warren county *Cornelius Elliott came from Licking county |
| 1836 | *Daniel Toland
came from
Montgomery county *John Fahr with wife and four children came from Perry county *Wm H. Abbott |
| 1838 | Didrich Schulte of Germany |
| St. Laurentius (or St. Lawrence Roman Catholic Church) |
Organized in 1856 by Father Henry J. Muckerheide in the school house of Sub-district No. 1. In the Autumn of 1858, a brick church was built and dedicated by Father Muckerheide. In 1878, the society built a two story brick school house in which they held school during 3-6 months out of the year. |
| Evangelical Lutheran St. James Church of Franklin & Dinsmore twps | In 1833, a log house was built for Pastor rev. John Henry Ferdinand Joesting, which, for a while, served as a parsonage, school, and church. In 1854, a brick church was built near the site of the old log building. In 1871, a church was built in Anna because most of the members had relocated there. |
| Anna M.E. Church | Formerly known as Mt. Gilead M.E. Church. Organized in 1833 at the house of Richard C. Dill by revs D.D. Davidson and James Smith. Regular meetings were held at the houses of Richard C Dill and Jospeh Park. In 1840, meetings were held at the house of Mary J. Young. In 1841, a log church was built. In 1858, a new frame church was dedicated by Rev. P.G. Goode. |
| Roman Catholic Church of the "Immaculate Conception" | Services were held at member's homes and old school houses. Most parishoners were of German heritage. In 1867, a church was built for their use. |
| Botkins M.E. Church | Organized in 1833/4 at the house of Richard Botkin by Rev. Daniel D. Davidson, assisted by Rev. James Smith. Meetings were held at the house of Richard Botkin for several years until the meetings were moved to a log cabin house that already stood in Botkins. In 1841, a hewed log church was built. In the 1860's a frame church building was built. In 1881 a brick church was built. |